Sauce can make or break barbecue. At Midwood Smokehouse, their signature sauces are more than condiments—they’re part of the identity. From classic Carolina vinegar to mustard and sweet “Matt’s Original”, their sauce lineup delivers balance, punch, and versatility.
In this guide, we’ll cover:
- The types of Midwood Smokehouse sauces available
- Flavor profiles and best uses
- How to order sauces (retail, portions, pricing)
- Ingredient and allergen breakdowns
- Tips and pairing suggestions
- A detailed FAQ (15+ questions)
If you want the definitive reference on Midwood BBQ sauce, you’ve come to the right place.
View Full: Midwood Smokehouse menu with prices
Order Now: Midwood Smokehouse Delivery®.
Types of Sauce Offered by Midwood Smokehouse
Midwood sells and serves several sauce styles, each tailored to a regional BBQ tradition or a signature twist:
| Sauce Name | Style / Region | Description / Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Matt’s Original | Signature Sweet & Tangy | Their flagship house sauce — a balanced BBQ sauce that blends sweetness, acidity, and smokiness. Sold retail. |
| Eastern NC Vinegar | Vinegar-based, thin | Light, tangy, ideal for pork; classic North Carolina style. Retail bottle available. |
| SC Mustard Sauce | Mustard-forward | Mustard-based sauce (South Carolina style) with tang and spice. Available for purchase. |
Midwood markets these sauces for retail sale (bottles) so fans can “Bring our signature flavors home.”
They also use these sauces in their plates and catering menus. For example, their “Party Packs / Group To-Go” menu shows sauce offerings at “$5 per Pint, $8 per Quart” in the catering menu.
Flavor Profiles & Best Uses
Understanding how each sauce tastes and pairs can help you get the most from your BBQ.
1. Matt’s Original
- Flavor: Balanced sweet, smoky, tangy
- Best with: Brisket, ribs, pulled pork, burnt ends
- Usage: Can be used as finishing sauce or dipping side
2. Eastern NC Vinegar
- Flavor: Sharp, tangy, acidic, minimal sweetness
- Best with: Pulled pork, chopped pork, lean meats
- Usage: Used as a thin mop sauce or poured over meat
3. SC Mustard
- Flavor: Slightly sweet, tangy mustard base
- Best with: Pork, chicken, slaws
- Usage: Ideal for sandwiches, or as a lighter sauce option
Many Midwood fans online talk about how their house vinegar and habanero sauces stand out.
They even have a somewhat secret “cola sauce” recipe used on burnt ends — combining soda reduction + ketchup, molasses, etc. That shows their innovation ethos.
How to Order Midwood Sauce
You can get Midwood sauces in a few different ways:
- Retail bottles: On the online store, you can buy bottles in your choice of style: Matt’s Original, Eastern NC Vinegar, or SC Mustard. Price ~$9.99 each.
- Catering / party packs: Their group menus list sauces offered at $5 per pint / $8 per quart alongside party packs.
- In-house use: Restaurants include these sauces with plate orders or provide them in sauce cups for dipping.
When ordering BBQ plates or group catering, you can often request which sauce style you prefer, or get multiple options.
Ingredient & Allergen Insights
Midwood’s BBQ sauces contain a mix of classic ingredients and signature elements. Based on public sources and BBQ sauce norms, here’s a speculative breakdown:
| Sauce | Likely Key Ingredients | Possible Allergens / Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Matt’s Original | Tomato/ketchup, molasses, vinegar, sugar, spices, smoke | May contain soy (e.g. soy sauce), gluten traces from thickeners, mustard, corn syrup |
| Eastern NC Vinegar | Vinegar (apple cider), salt, pepper, red pepper flakes | Usually gluten-free if no flour used; cross-contact possible |
| SC Mustard | Mustard, vinegar, sugar, spices, possibly tomato | Mustard allergen, possibly gluten if thickened, soy in spice blends |
Because Midwood also supplies a printed allergen guide for sides and sauces in their party menus, they acknowledge cross-contamination risks in their kitchens.
If you have food allergies, ask your location to view their official sauce‑ingredient sheet before ordering.
Tips & Strategies for Using Midwood Sauce
- Mix styles: Try a split order with vinegar and mustard to contrast flavors.
- Use sparingly: Their signature sauce is rich — a little goes a long way.
- Sauce on side: Ask for sauce on the side so you control how much you use.
- Taste test: When first trying, sample meat with no sauce, then add drops to see what it does.
- Take-home bottles: Order an extra bottle to carry home and enhance leftovers.
- Pair to meat: Lean pork + vinegar, fattier brisket + sweet sauce, chicken + mustard.
- Reheat with sauce: If reheating leftovers, brush light sauce on before warming to intensify flavor.
FAQ – Midwood Smokehouse Sauce
How many sauce types does Midwood Smokehouse offer?
Midwood Smokehouse is known for its trio of bold and flavorful house-made sauces: Matt’s Original, Eastern NC Vinegar, and South Carolina Mustard. Each sauce caters to a distinct regional BBQ flavor profile, ensuring there’s something for everyone—whether you like sweet, tangy, or mustard-based sauces.
Are Midwood sauces available for purchase?
Yes, you can buy Midwood Smokehouse sauces in retail bottles either directly from their locations or through online ordering when available. These sauces are a popular take-home item, especially for fans who want to recreate the flavor at home or give BBQ-themed gifts.
What is Matt’s Original sauce like?
Matt’s Original is Midwood’s signature house sauce. It’s a well-balanced sweet and smoky BBQ sauce with rich tomato base notes and subtle heat. This sauce complements smoked brisket, pulled pork, and ribs perfectly—making it the go-to option for most Midwood fans.
Is the vinegar sauce spicy?
The Eastern NC Vinegar Sauce has a bold, peppery tang with a noticeable kick but it’s not overwhelming. It’s crafted in true Eastern North Carolina tradition, where vinegar is king. The spice is from crushed red pepper and black pepper, but it doesn’t overpower the meat—it enhances it.
Does the SC Mustard sauce contain mustard seeds?
Yes, South Carolina Mustard Sauce is built around mustard as a base ingredient, including mustard seeds. It delivers a tangy flavor with hints of sweetness and depth, commonly paired with pork but delicious on everything from chicken to turkey.
Are Midwood Smokehouse sauces gluten-free?
Some sauces—especially vinegar-based styles—may be gluten-free, but not all sauces are guaranteed to be. Matt’s Original and others may contain soy sauce or thickening agents that include gluten. If you have celiac disease or gluten intolerance, it’s best to check with your local Midwood Smokehouse for allergen information.
Are these sauces dairy-free?
Generally, yes. Most traditional barbecue sauces, including those at Midwood Smokehouse, do not include dairy ingredients. However, it’s always wise to double-check if you have a dairy allergy, especially if trying any specialty or seasonal sauces.
Can I order multiple sauce styles in one meal?
Absolutely! Midwood Smokehouse allows you to mix and match sauces—especially with plate orders, combo meals, and catering trays. You can request sauces on the side or in multiple portions to sample all three varieties.
What is the cost of a retail sauce bottle?
Retail sauce bottles from Midwood Smokehouse are typically priced around $9.99, though prices may vary slightly depending on location and availability. They’re often available at the counter or checkout area and sometimes sold in gift packs.
What catering sizes are available for sauces?
For larger gatherings or catering orders, Midwood Smokehouse offers sauce by the pint (around $5) or quart (about $8). These portions are ideal for events, BBQ parties, or meal prep.
Is the cola sauce a standard menu item?
Cola sauce is not a regular feature on the standard menu. It’s a specialty or experimental sauce, often used in dishes like burnt ends or limited-time specials. It features cola as a flavor base, offering a sweet, rich, and slightly caramelized note.
Can I request sauce on the side?
Yes, Midwood Smokehouse offers sauce cups on the side upon request. Whether you’re dining in or taking out, you can ask for any of their sauces to be served separately for dipping or drizzling at your own pace.
Do sauces rotate with the seasons?
Occasionally, seasonal sauces or limited editions are introduced—especially during holiday months or special promotions. While the three core sauces remain constant, you might spot something new depending on when you visit.
Do sauce purchases earn rewards points?
Yes, if you’re part of Midwood’s loyalty or rewards program, buying bottled sauces in-store or online often counts as a merchandise purchase, making it eligible for points accumulation. Be sure to scan your rewards ID at checkout.
How should I store leftover sauce?
To maintain freshness, any leftover sauce—whether from the table or a retail bottle—should be refrigerated after opening. It’s best to use within a few weeks for peak flavor. Always check the label for specific storage instructions if provided.
Why Midwood’s Sauce Line Is Noteworthy
- Diverse styles: Covers vinegar, mustard, and sweet blends.
- Retail access: Fans can bring the flavor home with bottle sales.
- Experimentation mindset: The cola sauce on burnt ends shows Midwood’s drive to innovate.
- Pairing flexibility: Their sauces allow varied combos with different meats.
- Catering scalability: Sauces are part of their party menu and sold in bulk sizes.